Judicial Review and Interpretation: Have the Courts Become Sovereign When Interpreting the Constitution?

Publication Year
2005

Type

Book Chapter
Abstract

In a sermon preached before King George I in 1717, Bishop Benjamin Hoadly warned, "[W]hoever has an absolute Authority to interpret any written, or spoken Laws; it is He, who is truly the Law-giver, to all Intents and Purposes; and not the Person who first wrote, or spoke them." In the twentieth century United States, Hoadly's warning against ecclesiastical authority has been taken to describe the system of constitutional interpretation and judicial review under the U.S. Constitution. Although the problem of reconciling democracy and constitutionalism is a persistent and complex one, in practice the courts have not "become sovereign" and displaced republican government.

Book Title
Institutions of Democracy: The Judicial Branch
Publisher
Oxford University Press
City
New York